Creative Genius vs McKinsey QuantumBlack
McKinsey will deliver a beautiful 80-slide AI strategy deck for $400K–$2M. We'll ship working AI software for 5% of that. Both have their place.
Side-by-side
Creative Genius
Pros
- Engineers who build, not just advisors who recommend
- 6-week scopes, not 18-month engagements
- Fixed-price, no hourly billing
- You keep the source code
- Direct senior engineer access on every call
Trade-offs
- No global brand-name letterhead
- No team of 50 analysts on standby
- Won't help you justify a $5B AI initiative to a hostile board
Pricing
$7.5K–$45K for strategy engagements
McKinsey QuantumBlack
Pros
- Brand-name credibility for board-level approval
- Massive global benchmark dataset
- Deep relationships with Fortune 50 CIOs
- Suitable for trillion-dollar capital allocation decisions
Trade-offs
- 10–40x our pricing for equivalent strategic output
- Junior consultants doing the actual work
- Recommendations rarely translate cleanly into shipped software
- Months of stakeholder management before any code
Pricing
$400K–$2M+ for AI strategy engagements
Pick Creative Genius if…
- You want strategy + execution from the same team
- Budget is under $500K
- You value speed over consensus
- You want code, not a deck
Pick McKinsey QuantumBlack if…
- You're a Fortune 100 making a $1B+ AI bet
- Board needs Tier-1 consulting brand for cover
- Strategy alone is the deliverable
Our honest verdict
McKinsey's AI practice is excellent for $50M+ enterprise transformations. For everything else, you're paying enormous premium for brand validation you may not need.
FAQs
Is Creative Genius cheaper than McKinsey QuantumBlack?
Depends. $7.5K–$45K for strategy engagements vs $400K–$2M+ for AI strategy engagements. The honest answer is in the verdict at the bottom of this page — neither is always cheaper. We pick based on what's right for your situation.
When should I pick McKinsey QuantumBlack over Creative Genius?
You're a Fortune 100 making a $1B+ AI bet Plus: Board needs Tier-1 consulting brand for cover Plus: Strategy alone is the deliverable
When does Creative Genius beat McKinsey QuantumBlack?
You want strategy + execution from the same team Also: Budget is under $500K Also: You value speed over consensus Also: You want code, not a deck
Can you work alongside McKinsey QuantumBlack?
Often yes. We're not religious about being the only provider. If you've already invested in McKinsey QuantumBlack and want us to fill specific gaps, we'll scope to that.
Other comparisons
Want to see if we're the right fit?
Free 30-minute discovery call. Fixed-price scope after. Full source-code transfer at handoff. Cancel anytime.
Book a free call